Current Issue

Mar. 20, 2013

Vol. 113, No. 9

Alumni Scene

Can women have it all? A conversation continues

By Jennifer Altmann
Published in the March 20, 2013, issue

Anne-Marie Slaughter ’80 and President Tilghman discuss work-life balance.
Anne-Marie Slaughter ’80 and President Tilghman discuss work-life balance.

Anne-Marie Slaughter ’80 is one of the most prominent women on the Princeton faculty, but as an undergraduate she was afraid to seek out high-profile positions, she said in a conversation with President Tilghman on women’s leadership and work-life ­balance.

As an undergraduate, “I didn’t dare really try for anything that would have put me in a leadership position,” such as student government or The Daily Princetonian, Slaughter said at the event Feb. 22, the eve of Alumni Day. “I was too scared to try ... I didn’t think I was a leader until between [the ages of] 35 and 40.” Referring to a 2011 study that found female Princeton undergraduates were underrepresented in the most visible leadership positions, she added, “I want to say to young women, ‘Try being out front.’”

Slaughter, the Bert G. Kerstetter ’66 University Professor of Politics and International Affairs, has become a leading figure in the debate over why women still lag behind men in leadership positions since her cover story in The Atlantic, “Why Women Still Can’t Have it All,” was published last summer.

“Every generation has to have this conversation,” Slaughter said, pointing out, in the audience of more than 500 people in Richardson Auditorium, Lisa Belkin ’82, author of a much-discussed 2003 article, “The Opt-Out Revolution.” The article described ­Princeton-educated women who were quitting high-powered careers. Young women today “grew up absolutely being told they could do anything,” Slaughter said. “They’re looking at women ahead of them and they are saying, ‘This ­doesn’t look so easy, and I want better choices.’”

Tilghman brought up Sheryl Sandberg, the COO of Facebook, who has said that women hold themselves back from becoming leaders.

Slaughter lamented that female students at Princeton are “not raising their hand as much, not pushing as much,” adding, “We do have to combat the ways in which we are socialized.” She agreed with Sandberg that “there are many barriers in the workplace,” and recalled her inability to get women promoted when she worked for two years as the director of policy planning at the State Depart­ment. 

Slaughter has put more blame on employers for failing to adopt family-friendly policies.

Tilghman said: “In general, women are allowed a narrower personality range than men. You cannot afford to be shy and retiring, because that will be stereotyped, nor can you afford to be at the other end of the spectrum with those sharp elbows. ... Neither of those extremes are problematic for men.” 

The conversation continued after the event at a networking reception for students and alumni at Chancellor Green, where Stephanie Schnabel ’87 said she worried that Slaughter’s ­message was too negative. “Women in college may take a more defeatist attitude and think they have to choose between career and family,” she said. “We owe it to the next generation to chip away at the problem.” 

Iveta Gigova *96 said what was left out of the conversation was “maternal instincts. I’m the one juggling child-care arrangements, partly because of maternal instincts and partly because of how my husband and I were raised.”

Others were dismayed that younger women must continue to grapple with these issues. Said Belkin: “I’m astounded that we are still discussing this!”

Post Comments
2 Responses to Can women have it all? A conversation continues

Susan Meyer Says:

2013-03-18 09:35:30

Great article. I look forward to seeing the young ladies running the Princeton Sustainable fashion week event in April. They are studying and working on a passion all at the same time. This is a great habit to form early in life. My career has taken me so many places, from a starting position to a VP position in a larger company to a founder of my own company, all the while raising my children and being a supportive wife. Women can do anything. The titles and positions will come with the hard work. The key point is do it because you want to, not because you have to or to prove anything. Hard work is never hard if you love it. If it grows and progresses naturally you will be able to digest it, nurture it, and it will grow to be lasting and successful. The measure will be, and should be, your own -- title or not. Taking action and putting in the time should be the focus; the rest comes with good intention. Most important, giving back and mentoring to others. I hope these will be my most important titles.

Jennifer Larkey Balink '87 Says:

2013-03-18 09:37:58

I can believe we're still talking about this. What I remember most clearly from Lisa's article (at least, I think that's where I read it) is the idea that women won't really have equality until men choose to do the things that are traditionally women's work - choose as in they'd prefer to head down that path with intention. I don't see that seismic shift happening any time soon.
Tell us what you think about
Can women have it all? A conversation continues
Enter the word as it appears in the picture below
By submitting a comment, you agree to PAW's comment posting policy.
CURRENT ISSUE: Mar. 20, 2013
Related stories
Alumni Scene