In response to: A Class Without Grades

Martin Schell ’74

5 Years Ago

Timeless Wisdom

What a wonderful essay, a real exemplar of qualitative analysis. Duberman seems to channel Lao Tzu (Tao Te Ching #18) in his syllogism about authority versus authoritarianism: “When Tao is lost, age replaces maturity, information replaces understanding, and technique replaces originality.”

I particularly liked his insight about vociferous discussions in the class: “Activity, when manic, was itself a form of passivity, though disguised to look like its opposite. ‘Busyness,’ like ‘boredom,’ could serve as a device for avoiding self-confrontation.” This comment could apply to the current climate of political unrest as well, both on campus and off campus.

Join the conversation

Plain text

No HTML tags allowed.

Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.