Dedicating Princeton University’s New Medallion

Placeholder author icon
By Christopher L. Eisgruber ’83

Published Nov. 23, 2016

3 min read

On October 22, 2016, we unveiled a new medallion embedded in the walkway in front of Nassau Hall. I was joined at the podium by Bob Durkee ’69, Vice President and Secretary of the University, and Brent Henry ’69, Vice Chair of the Board of Trustees and Chair of its Wilson Legacy Review Committee. In attendance were alumni and parents participating in the Alumni Volunteer Weekend. Several people suggested that my remarks might be of more general interest, and I reprint them below.

We come together this morning to recast the University’s informal motto, adding words spoken by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, Class of 1976, to those uttered by President Woodrow Wilson, Class of 1879. By so doing, we participate once again in the vibrant evolution of the traditions that shape this University’s identity.

The evolution of those traditions brings to mind the words of another Princetonian who preceded Justice Sotomayor on the Supreme Court and who, like her, served this nation with distinction. In one of the most widely quoted and influential dissenting opinions ever written, Justice John Marshall Harlan, Class of 1920, said that the American Constitution’s guarantee of liberty took its meaning from “the traditions from which [our country] developed as well as the traditions from which it broke.” “That tradition,” he added, “is a living thing.” [1]

The traditions of this University, like those of our country and our Constitution, are living things. We do them no justice if we regard them as relics deserving of uncritical adulation, mindless obeisance, or ossified preservation. We give those traditions their due—we honor them most faithfully—only if we cultivate them actively in light of the values and purposes at the heart of this great liberal arts University.

This loving stewardship, this interpretation and reinterpretation of our shared heritage, dates back to the origins of our school. We have persisted and we have changed. We began as a tiny liberal arts college founded to educate young men for the Presbyterian ministry. In Wilson’s era we became a research university. In Sotomayor’s time, we opened our gates to a wider world, becoming at once more diverse, more international, and more intellectually eminent than ever before.

The University’s evolution continues to this day and will continue beyond it. Princeton is the better for the changes that have happened, and those changes have made Princeton more true to the very best values that have defined us since our inception.

Woodrow Wilson’s memorable phrase, “Princeton in the Nation’s Service,” spoken at the University’s 150th anniversary in 1896, captured one of those values. It expressed this University’s long-standing commitment to service and leadership. Wilson’s words inspired generations of Princeton students and alumni. His reference to the nation was, however, incomplete and exclusive. In 1996, my predecessor, Princeton’s marvelous eighteenth president, Harold Shapiro *64, addressed that exclusivity by reinterpreting Wilson’s idea and Princeton’s tradition to embrace service not only to this nation but to all nations.

Today, we again revise the motto, this time to correct forms of partiality inherent in the very concept of nationhood. As Justice Sotomayor pointed out in her speech accepting the Woodrow Wilson Award in 2014, the concept is partial because it values service to the state over service to people or individuals. Coincidentally or not, it is also partial in a way that hints at the racism that marred Wilson’s towering achievements at this University and on the world stage.

The word “nation” comes from the Latin word for “birth,” and its English-language meaning suggests a people defined by ties of blood, ethnicity, or culture. By adding Sonia Sotomayor’s words to Wilson’s, we recognize our responsibility to serve not only our state or our tribe but all members of the human community.

Today’s modest ceremony may soon be forgotten. But for so long as this medallion remains here, in this meaningful and beloved place, it will remind students, faculty, staff, alumni, and visitors to our campus of this University’s values. It will remind them of those who helped to build the institution we cherish, and it will remind them, too, of our collective responsibility simultaneously to respect the past, to acknowledge forthrightly its deficiencies, and to improve upon it.

The medallion will remind us, in short, of the traditions from which today’s Princeton developed and the traditions from which we have broken. Our traditions are, as our fellow alumnus John Marshall Harlan said, a living thing. I am grateful to all of you for your partnership not only here today, but also in the many shared endeavors through which we steward and cultivate what we inherit from those who preceded us for the benefit of those who will follow us.

Thank you for being here, and thank you for your support of this very special University.

1. Poe v. Ullman, 367 US 497 at 542 (Harlan, J., dissenting).

4 Responses

Norman Ravitch *62

6 Years Ago

What Would Be an Accurate Motto?

Yes we would all like a motto which inflates our pride and self-esteem. But all the universities in Europe were first designed for the training of people in the professions: law, medicine, religion, teaching. The rulers of the day, whether clerical or lay, intended the universities to train their bureaucrats, whether as lawyers, judges, officials, or members of the church hierarchy. Service was defined in this way, not in some grandiose idea of service to humanity. A university education might help you to discover heretics and witches so they could be burned at the stake. It might help you to detect traitors and criminals also so you might dispatch them from this life as soon as possible. It might help you to find the means of appropriating the property of peasants and poor farmers for the benefit of big landowners. It might help you to devise laws helpful to one regime or another. It might help you save lives or end lives through a certain understanding of the human body and its diseases and afflictions. But it certainly was not designed for something grand like the current or the former Princeton motto. Perhaps a modern version of all this might be: Princeton can help you get a job some day! This might be appropriate considering the outrageous cost of an education.

Tad Lafountain ’72

8 Years Ago

This “informal” motto was approved...

This “informal” motto was approved by the Board of Trustees and then literally carved in stone. What would constitute a “formal” motto? The Commandments went through a somewhat similar vetting process and were delivered in the same medium; they’ve been treated as pretty formal for some time now.

It would be interesting to get Professor Singer’s thoughts on a motto that clearly elevates Homo Sapiens above all other inhabitants of our mortal coil. Inclusive? As functional societies, we’ve been around for all of maybe 30,000 out of 13.73 billion years, and yet we keep acting like we’re as good as it gets. Combined with recent events, that’s darned depressing.

Norman Ravitch *62

8 Years Ago

Instead of adding words from...

Instead of adding words from Supreme Justice Sotomayor to those of Woodrow Wilson, it would have been more appropriate to add words from Karl Marx, since Princeton has evolved from its original Calvinism through the Liberalism and Progressivism of Wilson to the Marxism of the Princeton faculty since the 1960s and 1970s. Sotomayor is a pale version of real Marxism since she dissolves it with ethnic nationalism and identity politics, something Marx would have abhorred. He would doubtless consider her a bourgeois ideologist or perhaps what Lenin called a “useful idiot.”

Rocky Semmes ’79

7 Years Ago

Refine the Informal Motto

Published online July 6, 2017

A first lesson in marketing is that a motto is best built to be brief, and should be crafted to strike like a bullet. All good intentions aside, the recently revised informal motto of the University falls far short of the mark (President's Page, Dec. 7). President Eisgruber ’83 must certainly be applauded for his embrace of change where it proves useful. In his own words, “The University’s evolution continues to this day and will continue beyond it.”

In that vein of continued evolution, the current motto should be refined at the earliest opportunity (and when determined as respectfully appropriate) to read “Princeton in Humanity’s Service.” Nothing could be more all-encompassing, noble, and conclusive; and as any good salesperson will tell you, it also packs a proper punch.

Join the conversation

Plain text

Full name and Princeton affiliation (if applicable) are required for all published comments. For more information, view our commenting policy. Responses are limited to 500 words for online and 250 words for print consideration.

Related News

Newsletters.
Get More From PAW In Your Inbox.

Learn More

Title complimentary graphics