Philosophy is alive and well in America, Romano '76 argues

i-68b30a30c108bcacbb7d57995c6fed12-carlin-roman.png

New book: America the Philosophical, by Carlin Romano ’76 (Knopf)

The author: Romano, a finalist for the 2005 Pulitzer Prize in criticism, writes for The Chronicle of Higher Education as a critic-at-large and teaches philosophy at Ursinus College. He served as a literary critic of The Philadelphia Inquirer for 25 years and edited the 2010 fiction collection Philadelphia Noir.  

The book: Americans may joke about philosophy or simply ignore it, but Romano rejects the notion that the nation is anti-intellectual and “unphilosophical.” Instead, he sees a lively intellectual culture with pragmatic philosophers in realms as diverse as talk shows and the sciences. Several Princetonians play a role Romano’s wide-ranging story, including John Rawls ’43 *50, Edward Said ’57, Cornel West *80, and Michael Eric Dyson *93.

Opening lines: “The moment wiseguy journalists heard about Lou Marinoff’s professional bent – lobbying for philosophers to practice as therapists, to go head-to-head with psychologists and psychiatrists – the jokes and headlines flew fast and funny: ‘I Shrink, Therefore I Am’; ‘An Aphorism a Day Keeps the Doctor Away’; ‘The Uncompensated Life Is Not Worth Living’; ‘How Many Philosophers Can You Fit on the Head of a Couch?’

“Marinoff knew how reporters mock everything, and he had the clips to prove it, but the middle-aged CCNY philosophy professor also understood the importance of the counter-jab. …”

Reviews: Anthony Gottleib of The New York Times noted that America the Philosophical counters the viewpoint of popular books such as Idiot America: How Stupidity Became a Virtue in the Land of the Free. “The fallacy of such books, as Romano argues, is that they take some rotten parts for the largely nutritious whole,” Gottleib wrote. … Publishers Weekly said the book “seeks to shift our definition of philosophy from an emphasis on reason and truth-finding to philosophy as a form of persuasion that aims to find better solutions to problems.”

0 Responses

Join the conversation

Plain text

Full name and Princeton affiliation (if applicable) are required for all published comments. For more information, view our commenting policy. Responses are limited to 500 words for online and 250 words for print consideration.

Related News

Newsletters.
Get More From PAW In Your Inbox.

Learn More

Title complimentary graphics